Julien Valroff's weblog and personal homepage
My experience without Adobe® Flash™ Player
Adobe® recently announced they have (temporarily) stopped working on the amd64 version of their Flash™ Player for GNU/Linux.
The previous releases contain a big security issue, which makes them totally unusable.
As I didn’t want to wait until the flashplugin-nonfree package to be updated to support the i386 plugin through nspluginwrapper (as suggested in #586273), I have decided to simply switch to the free alternative: gnash.
After a few hours with it, I am now able to use most of the websites I usually visit, including Youtube and Dailymotion.
Note that I use Iceweasel, which does not support WebM (for now), nor H.264 (which will never be supported by Mozilla).
Youtube support is brought by a Greasemonkey user script available at: http://turanct.wordpress.com/2010/02/25/gnash-youtube/
The only tiny drawback is that the videos load in pause mode. For now, everything else seems to work fine.
Users of other browers (Chromium, Safari, Opera) can try their HTML5 beta: http://www.youtube.com/html5
It is even easier for Dailymotion, as the videos on their HTML5 beta program are encoded in the Ogg Theora format, which is natively supported by Iceweasel/Firefox >= 3.5.
To ease things, I have written a small Greasemonkey script which simply automatically redirects www.dailymotion.com to openvideo.dailymotion.com. This script can be downloaded here.
The drawback is that videos won’t play before they are loaded completely, which is not a big problem anyway.
I still cannot play the videos avilable on Vimeo, and have noticed while wirting this post that the Flash™ file uploader of WordPress didn’t work with gnash (obviously, WP provides an alternative way for file upload).
I will go on with this experience as long as I do not see major issue with gnash.
I will also update this post, or add comments, if I encounter other issues, or find any alternatives.
I would be curious to read your comments if you have run similar experience.
| Print article | This entry was posted by Julien on June 19, 2010 at 14:26, and is filed under Weblog. Follow any responses to this post through RSS 2.0. Both comments and pings are currently closed. |
Comments are closed.
about 2 months ago
I just did the same (after having pursued various alternatives in the past few days, from nspluginwrapper to schroot-ed 32bit iceweasel/chromium).
The last time I tried gnash was a few years ago and I’m happy to report that nowadays it’s *much* better.
Thanks for making me try again.
about 2 months ago
I’ve been using gnash/swfdec for ages and not come across major problems.
The main site I had a problem with was vimeo, but clive works with that.
about 2 months ago
I personally just download everything. I use youtube-dl for youtube, the download links provided by blip.tv, viddler, and vimeo, the get-flash-videos script for many other sites, and a web-based video download bookmarklet for things that doesn’t work for. Between those, I haven’t run into sites I can’t download video from.
about 2 months ago
What a pain Adobe is. They are cutting the tree underneath themselves, and will eventually fall. It’s just a bit painful to wait until that happens.
about 2 months ago
I have been without flash for years because it made my browser unstable, crash and it’s closed-source (I don’t have any other closed-source software on my computer, not because of religious reasons but because it just integrates/works better if you use a free operating system).
For video websites I use cclive which works really well. You can let it stream to mplayer before it finished downloading the file. Also, you can define a shortcut in your browser which launches cclive with the URL of the current tab.
about 2 months ago
Here is the best I could find for vimeo until now: http://userscripts.org/scripts/show/56677
This user script displays a direct link to the video download on vimeo, and the mp4 video simply plays within Iceweasel through the Totem plugin.
about 2 months ago
Even though I’m not fond of their flash plugin (especially its performance on amd64 ever since), but Gnash never did it for me either :-/
I tried playing with youtube/html5 with Chromium but for the first time came to discovery that a lot of videos are actually not available. Since quite frankly I’m most biased towards the option of not using any kind of plugin, open source or not open source.
But since my still favorite browser Iceweasel/Firefox does not have webm included (except nightly builds) in order to have all my videos played I turned to Adobe again
I had this script edited and for now it’s working for me (http://foolcontrol.org/debian-amd64-flash-installer.sh) until then I hope that in near future Firefox4 and HTML5 will release me of my flash player misery
about 2 months ago
Your script however downloads and installs a totally insecure version of the Flash Player.
I would rather not use this!
about 2 months ago
I tried Adobe-Tools and it’s providing me with the latest 10.1 flash player http://github.com/dolphinaura/Adobe-Tools